How to Deal with Negative Book Reviews
Negative book reviews are an inevitable part of being an author, whether you're traditionally published or self-published. As writers, we pour our hearts and souls into our work, so it's only natural to feel a sting when someone criticizes it. However, negative reviews don't have to be the end of the world. In fact, they can be valuable learning experiences and opportunities for growth. In this guide, we'll explore strategies for dealing with negative book reviews, with a particular focus on self-publishing authors.
This article may contain affiliate links. This means we might make a small commission on anything you buy through a link on this page. This comes at no extra cost to you. Commissions help us to run our free 7 Day Story Writing Challenges.
Examples from Famous Authors: To illustrate that negative reviews are not exclusive to aspiring or self-published authors, let's take a look at some famous authors who have received their fair share of criticism:
J.K. Rowling - The author of the immensely popular Harry Potter series faced criticism from some literary circles for her writing style and storytelling techniques, particularly in the earlier books of the series. Despite this, the Harry Potter books went on to become some of the best-selling novels of all time, proving that negative reviews don't always reflect the opinions of the majority of readers.
Stephen King - Often hailed as the king of horror fiction, Stephen King has received his share of negative reviews over the years. Some critics have dismissed his work as formulaic or lacking in depth, but King's legions of fans continue to devour his novels with enthusiasm, demonstrating that negative reviews are just one part of the literary landscape.
J.R.R. Tolkien - The Lord of the Rings trilogy is now considered a classic of fantasy literature, but when it was first published, it received mixed reviews from critics. Some found Tolkien's writing style overly verbose and his world-building too complex, while others praised the depth and richness of his storytelling. Despite the initial criticism, Tolkien's books have endured and continue to captivate readers around the world.
The Evolution of Criticism:
Criticism has evolved with the rise of digital technology, shifting from traditional literary circles to online platforms. The internet has democratized critique, allowing anyone to share opinions on platforms like Goodreads and Amazon. However, this accessibility has also led to challenges, including the proliferation of opinions and the potential for harsh or malicious feedback. Algorithms further complicate matters, shaping readers' perceptions and influencing purchasing decisions. Despite these challenges, the evolution of criticism has also brought positive changes, fostering a more intimate relationship between authors and readers and providing valuable resources for aspiring writers. Overall, while the landscape of criticism continues to evolve, it remains an essential aspect of literary discourse in the digital age.
The Psychological Impact of Criticism:
Impact on Confidence: Negative book reviews can have a significant impact on an author's confidence and self-esteem. Receiving criticism, especially if it's harsh or unfounded, can lead authors to doubt their abilities and question their worth as writers.
Fear of Rejection: Authors may develop a fear of rejection or reluctance to share their work following negative reviews. This fear can be paralyzing, hindering creativity and preventing authors from pursuing their passion for writing.
Validation Seeking: Authors may become overly reliant on external validation, seeking praise and approval from readers and critics to validate their worth as writers. This constant need for validation can be draining and unsustainable in the long run.
Emotional Distress: Negative reviews can evoke a range of negative emotions, including sadness, anger, frustration, and disappointment. Authors may struggle to cope with these emotions, leading to increased stress and emotional distress.
Imposter Syndrome: Negative reviews can exacerbate imposter syndrome, a psychological phenomenon characterized by feelings of inadequacy and self-doubt despite evidence of success. Authors may feel like frauds or imposters, doubting their talent and fearing that they will be exposed as frauds.
Comparison Trap: Authors may fall into the comparison trap, comparing themselves unfavorably to other writers who receive more praise or recognition. This comparison can be demoralizing and undermine an author's sense of accomplishment and self-worth.
Perfectionism: Negative reviews can fuel perfectionism, leading authors to obsess over every detail of their work and strive for unattainable standards of perfection. This perfectionism can be detrimental to creativity and productivity, stifling innovation and experimentation.
Cognitive Distortions: Authors may engage in cognitive distortions, such as catastrophizing or overgeneralizing, in response to negative reviews. These distorted thinking patterns can exacerbate feelings of hopelessness and despair, leading authors to adopt a defeatist attitude towards their writing.
Self-Care Neglect: Authors may neglect self-care in favor of obsessing over negative reviews or seeking validation from external sources. This neglect can have detrimental effects on their physical and mental well-being, leading to burnout and exhaustion.
Coping Strategies: Despite the psychological impact of negative reviews, authors can employ various coping strategies to manage their emotions and maintain their mental health. These strategies may include practicing self-compassion, seeking support from friends and fellow writers, focusing on the positive aspects of their work, and developing resilience in the face of criticism.
Understanding the Nature of Negative Reviews:
Before we dive into how to handle negative reviews, it's important to understand that not all negative reviews are created equal. Some may offer thoughtful critiques that can help you improve as a writer, while others may simply be the result of personal preference or misunderstanding. Learning to differentiate between the two can help you respond appropriately.
Thoughtful Critiques vs. Personal Preference:
Negative reviews can stem from various sources. Some reviewers provide thoughtful critiques that highlight areas for improvement in your work. These critiques may offer valuable insights into aspects such as plot development, character arcs, writing style, or pacing. Recognizing and appreciating these critiques is essential, as they can help you grow and refine your craft.
Misunderstandings and Personal Bias:
On the other hand, negative reviews might also arise from misunderstandings or personal bias. Readers bring their own preferences, experiences, and expectations to the table when consuming content. What doesn't resonate with one reader might be precisely what another enjoys. Understanding that not all negative feedback is necessarily indicative of flaws in your work is crucial. Sometimes, a negative review simply reflects a mismatch between the reader's expectations and the content provided.
Objective vs. Subjective Criticism:
It's essential to discern between objective and subjective criticism within negative reviews. Objective criticism focuses on tangible aspects of your work, such as technical errors, inconsistencies, or plot holes. This type of feedback provides concrete areas for improvement. Subjective criticism, on the other hand, pertains to personal tastes and preferences. While subjective feedback is still valid, it may not always align with your artistic vision or target audience.
Dealing with Negative Feedback:
Don't Take it Personally:
It's natural to feel hurt or defensive when faced with criticism, but it's important not to take negative reviews personally. Remember that everyone has different tastes and opinions, and what one reader dislikes, another may love. Instead of dwelling on the negativity, focus on the positive feedback you've received and the readers who have enjoyed your work.
Learn from Constructive Criticism:
Negative reviews, particularly those that offer constructive criticism, can be incredibly valuable to your growth as a writer. Instead of dismissing them outright, take the time to consider the feedback and see if there are any valid points you can use to improve your writing in the future. Keep in mind that even the most successful authors receive negative reviews, so you're in good company.
Here are some examples of how writers can learn from constructive criticism in negative reviews:
Plot Development:
Critique: "The plot felt predictable and lacked depth. I saw the twists coming from a mile away."
Learning: The writer can reflect on ways to add complexity and nuance to their plot, perhaps by introducing unexpected plot twists, developing multifaceted characters, or exploring deeper themes.
Characterization:
Critique: "The characters felt one-dimensional and lacked emotional depth. I couldn't connect with any of them."
Learning: The writer can focus on fleshing out their characters, giving them distinct personalities, motivations, and backstories. They may also explore techniques for creating more relatable and empathetic characters.
Writing Style:
Critique: "The prose felt overly verbose and distracting. Simplifying the language would improve readability."
Learning: The writer can evaluate their writing style, considering aspects such as sentence structure, word choice, and pacing. They may experiment with concise, impactful language to enhance clarity and engagement.
Pacing:
Critique: "The story dragged in the middle, losing momentum and interest. Tightening the pacing would keep readers engaged."
Learning: The writer can reassess the pacing of their narrative, ensuring that each scene serves a purpose and advances the plot. They may revise or condense slower sections to maintain tension and momentum throughout the story.
Dialogue:
Critique: "The dialogue felt stilted and unnatural, detracting from the authenticity of the characters' interactions."
Learning: The writer can focus on improving dialogue by paying attention to speech patterns, subtext, and character voice. They may study real-life conversations or dialogue-driven literature to refine their dialogue-writing skills.
By incorporating constructive criticism like these examples into their writing process, authors can identify areas for improvement and refine their craft over time. It's essential to approach negative reviews with an open mind and a willingness to learn, recognizing that even the most successful writers benefit from feedback and continuous growth.
Maintain Perspective:
While negative reviews can be disheartening, it's important to keep things in perspective. Remember that no book is universally loved, and even the most acclaimed works have their detractors. Instead of dwelling on the negative, focus on the readers who have connected with your book and the impact your writing has had on them.
Dealing with Negative Reviews as a Self-Publishing Author:
Self-publishing authors may face some unique challenges when it comes to negative reviews, but they also have more control over how they respond. Here are some tips specifically tailored to self-published authors:
Build a Support Network:
One of the advantages of self-publishing is the close-knit community of authors who are willing to support one another. Reach out to fellow writers for advice and encouragement when you receive a negative review. Chances are, they've been in your shoes and can offer valuable insights and perspective.
Focus on Marketing and Promotion:
Negative reviews can feel like a blow to your confidence, but don't let them derail your marketing efforts. Instead, focus on promoting your book to new readers who may not have seen the negative reviews. Highlight positive feedback and endorsements from readers who have enjoyed your work, and use social media and other platforms to connect with potential readers.
Consider Professional Editing and Proofreading:
One common complaint in negative reviews is poor editing or proofreading. To minimize the risk of receiving negative feedback for these reasons, consider investing in professional editing and proofreading services before publishing your book. While it may require an upfront investment, it can ultimately save you from receiving negative reviews and improve the overall quality of your work.
Respond Professionally:
If you do receive a negative review, resist the temptation to respond defensively or engage in arguments with the reviewer. Instead, take a deep breath and respond professionally, thanking the reviewer for their feedback and expressing your appreciation for their time and attention. Keep your response brief and respectful, and avoid getting into a back-and-forth exchange.
Negative book reviews are an inevitable part of being an author, but they don't have to define your success or dictate your future. By learning to handle negative reviews with grace and professionalism, you can turn them into valuable learning experiences and opportunities for growth. Remember that every author faces criticism at some point in their career, and it's how you respond to it that ultimately matters. Stay focused on your goals, keep writing, and don't let the fear of negative reviews hold you back from sharing your stories with the world.